DID THE RESURRECTION REALLY HAPPEN? SECTION B Illegal Trials First, Jesus was subjected to SIX TRIALS, three Roman and three Jewish. The actuality of a man called Pontius Pilate was considered fable UNTIL 1961, when archaeologist in the city of Caesarea uncovered a large inscription which read, "Pontius Pilate, Prefect of Judea, has presented the Tiberium to the Caesareans" and proves that such a Roman Governor did exist. The trials were: [1] Annas, the high priest [2] Caiaphas [3] the Sanhedrin [4] Pilate [5] Herod and [6] Pilate. History records that there were two Sanhedrin bodies. One consisted of 23 members and tried cases of capital punishment, another consisted of 71 members and was for trials of Heads of State, High Priest or matters of crimes against the Temple. The Sanhedrin of 23 was the most probable body that tried Jesus. Second, the very death by crucifixion was invented by the Persians who felt that the ground was concecrated to their Gods and a death on the ground would be against the gods; so they invented a method of death that would not defile the ground by placing the people on a stake and later a cross bar on a stake to lift them off the ground and allow the punishment of death to take place without defilement to the gods. Alexander the Great utilized the crucifixion as a major deterent force. The Romans felt the death was so degrading that a Roman citizen could not be crucified except by order of the Emperor and then this was usually after the person's citizenship was stripped from him. The Romans usually reserved the punishment for political cases. The very accusation against Christ was directed at political as you can read in Luke 23:2. The Romans added; However, another twist to the process of crucifixion. The added the "scourging" of the criminal. This consisted of a period of time that was set by the trial or could be set by the scourgers, themselves, of beating the accused with a form of brass knuckled fist and consisting of a minimum of six men. This usually left the facial features of the accused unrecognizable. The next step of the scourging consisted of the whipping of the accused with a Flagrum. This whip had numerous leather thongs of various lengths and braided into each of the thongs were bits of metal and bone. One Dr C.T. Davis has described the whipping with the flagrum in this manner: "The heavy whip is brought down with full force again and again across the accused's shoulder, back and legs. At first the heavy thongs cut through the skin, only. Then, as the the blows continue, they cut deeper into the subcutaneous tissues, producing first an oozing of blood from the capillaries and veins of the skin, and finally spurting arterial bleeding from the vessels in the underlying muscles. The small balls of lead first produce large deep bruises which are broken open by the subsequent blows. Finally the skin of the back is hanging in long ribbons and the entire area is an unrecognizable mass of torn, bleeding tissue. When it is determined by the Centurion that the prisoner in near death, the beating is finally stopped". A historian of the third century, Eusebius writes "The sufferer's veins were laid bare and the very muscles, sinews,and bowels of the victim were open to exposure. After this ordeal, Christ had a crown of thorns jammed into his head. The blood from this act must have been severe. Jesus was then subjected to another beating with a rod! After all this, our Lord was then forced to carry His "patibulum" to His place of execution. At the place of execution, Christ was nailed to his cross. History was devoid of any proof that nails were used until the discovery in 1968 of another tomb that contained the remains of a person who had been nailed, both hands and feet, to a cross. History then came to the defense of the Gospels and once, again, the Bible is proven correct. This theory neglects to consider the points of: [1] Jesus went through SIX TRIALS (3 Roman and 3 Jewish in less than 24 hours), [2] Had been scourged by the Romans. [3] Jesus was too weak to carry His patibulum. [4] Spikes had been driven through His hands and feet. [5] The Roman guard thrust his spear into Jesus's side and "blood and water came out". [6] Four Roman executioners confirmed the death of Jesus - could experienced executioners - four of them - really be wrong? [7] The women placed the 100 pounds of spices and wrap around Jesus and encased His body with the gummy substance that the spices would have made which would have made breathing difficult if not impossible [8] the tomb was cold and damp (40 degrees was suggested based on similar temperatures read in such tombs). This would have reduced any circulation of Jesus even further. [9] The two ton stone was lodged against the tomb opening. The stone was cut in such a manner to to make a tight seal against the opening and was, most likely, sealed further. The need to eliminate the smell of decomposition was great! [10] The Roman guard was posted outside the tomb and [11] The seal was present. This theory would then have you believe that this Jesus was revived by the coolness, burst out of the burial wrappings, pushed the boulder AWAY from the tomb, fought off this highly trained fighting guard unit and appeared to the Disciples as the Lord of Life with no after effects of such an ordeal. I, personally, would have to contend that this explanation is a miracle in itself! How could a man who had suffered these terrible punishments have been able to make His disciples believe that He was the Lord of Life and was victor over death? How could such an appearance have changed cowards into the most powerful force for God on earth as happened to EACH ONE of the disciples? The answer is SUCH AN APPEARANCE COULD NOT HAVE - ONLY THE RESURRECTION AS IT IS TOLD IN THE GOSPELS COULD ACCOUNT FOR SUCH A CHANGE. D. Passover Plot Hugh Schoenfield proposed a variation of the "swoon" theory in his book the PASSOVER PLOT. It is proposed in this book that Jesus had studied the scriptures and had structured His life in such a manner as to comply with the prophesies of the Messiah and convince the people that He was the Messiah. The conspirators consisted of Jesus, Joseph of Arimathea and a "young man". Now the plot was to have Jesus administered a drug that would feign His death. This was based on the fact that the "bitter water" given to crucified victims usually contained a narcotic to allow the person to sleep ***. Now the plan was to have Joseph take the body to the tomb and revive Jesus. The plot was short circuited when the guard thrust his spear into the side of Jesus. Jesus was taken to the tomb and revived but only lived a short time. Joseph and the "young man" then disposed of the body and emptied the tomb. Now this "young man" was mistaken to be the risen Lord by a hysterical Mary and later the confused disciples also mistook the "young man" as Jesus. History does not record that Joseph or the "young man" ever corrected these misimpressions. Mr Schoenfield does what most proponents of "alternate possibilities" do - he selects what "evidence" he wants and negates or ignores or disputes any "evidence" he does not like. He adopts a completely arbitrary basis for acceptance of evidence and "no rules" is the only rule. In the circumstance of the Roman guard placed at the tomb, Schoenfield rejects this as it is only mentioned in Matthew and if only one writer comments on the matter then it can be rejected. However, the matter of the spear is a mainstay of Schoenfield's theory and it is only mentioned in John! The very idea that the change in the disciples and the conversion of so many people could be attributed to a case of mistaken identity is so absurd as to be rejected as the ramblings of a man who finds the matter "foolish". III. CHRIST'S TOMB WAS EMPTY DUE TO SUPERNATURAL CAUSES A. Bodily Resurrection The Historical and Gospel facts show that each and every one of the so- called Natural explanations are invalid and would not hold up in a court of law. The reverse, though, is clearly shown in that the resurrection is a provable, logical, historical and factual occurance. The mind of man that will not accept the fact that God the Creator of all things injected His presence into the course of Human History, will also accept illogical, unproven fantasies to prevent being face to face with the living God, Jesus Christ our Lord and Savior. This being now shown as the ONLY true alternative, based on historical facts and logical deduction, then we can be assured of the promises he made to each of us because HE IS RISEN!!!!!! We follow the "Lamb of God" who died for us and we are aware of HIS sacrifice on our behalf. ****** END OF TEXT *****